rosemary
spice or herb / spice-rosemary
ローズマリー
Rosemary is the leaves of the herb rosemary, plus its extracts and essential oil. When added to food, bitterness stayed unchanged in some tests and increased in others.
On this page (8 sections)
Reading the bitterness
A table in a Japanese review describes the taste of rosemary as a strong aroma mixing wood, pine, flower, eucalyptus and clove notes, with a mildly bitter flavor. A product description for a household spice likewise states that its sweet fragrance and flavor with pronounced mild bitterness remain after the dish is finished. Both are descriptions of taste, not numerical measurements of bitterness intensity. As for the substance behind the bitterness, a table in another review lists carnosic acid (a diterpene) as common to rosemary and sage, but its bitter taste receptor column reads unknown, so this is not a result confirmed in receptor experiments.
There are tests in which adding rosemary did not increase bitterness. In pork meatballs and hamburger patties made with 0.05% ethanol extract, an 8-member trained panel found no significant difference in bitterness scores from the unsupplemented control (meatballs 0.4 and 0.4; hamburger patties 0.2 and 0.2). In a test adding 0.05% extract to cold-pressed flaxseed oil, the bitterness of the fresh oil was 1.9, the same as the unsupplemented oil. However, both are results at a single concentration, and in the flaxseed oil the day on which bitterness became unacceptable during storage (70 days at 25°C) was also the same as the unsupplemented oil.
In a test adding an aqueous extract to jelly candy, a 15-member trained panel found that bitterness scores did not differ from the unsupplemented candy at any of the low, medium or high amounts. However, the authors suggest that stevia, which has a bitter aftertaste, may have masked a difference, and they write that the extract itself is bitter. In a test adding rosemary to olive oil as fresh, dried or essential oil, bitterness at 6 months was 3.31 for the unsupplemented oil against 2.73 for fresh, 4.14 for dried and 3.44 for essential oil, with no significant differences; but there were only 6 assessors, and olive oil is itself bitter.
On the other hand, there are tests in which bitterness did appear. Bread made by replacing 1% of the flour with the residue left after rosemary essential oil was extracted received the highest bitterness score from 15 trained assessors, higher than bread made with oregano, lemon balm or spearmint residue. The carnosol and carnosic acid the authors cite as the reason are conjecture. In a test putting an extract in film wrapped around salami, a 12-member tasting panel found a significant difference in bitterness scores, but only some samples differed significantly from the control, and the panel was not made up of trained experts. In fermented thick cream, essential oil at 0.24% and 0.34% made bitterness and other attributes excessive and lowered overall acceptance, but individual bitterness scores were not confirmed. The samples were extracts, residue and essential oil, not the leaf itself.
Sources for this overview
Checked for this overview: The description of taste in the review table (a strong aroma and a mildly bitter flavor) was used at the start of paragraph 1.
Checked for this overview: The product description's statement about a flavor with pronounced mild bitterness was used in paragraph 1.
Checked for this overview: The review table's entry of carnosic acid and an unknown receptor was used at the end of paragraph 1.
Checked for this overview: The point that bitterness did not differ from the control in meatballs and hamburger patties was used in paragraph 2.
The Effect of Rosemary Extract on the Sensory Quality of Flaxseed Oil During Storage
Checked for this overview: The point that the bitterness of fresh flaxseed oil was the same was used in paragraph 2.
Checked for this overview: The point that bitterness was unchanged in jelly candy and that stevia may have had an influence was used in paragraph 3.
How storage time affects sensory, chemical, and physical characteristics of flavored olive oil
Checked for this overview: The point that bitterness showed no significant difference in olive oil was used in paragraph 3.
Checked for this overview: The point that the bitterness score was highest in bread made with residue was used in paragraph 4.
Evaluation of the Oxidative Status of Salami Packaged with an Active Whey Protein Film
Checked for this overview: The point that bitterness differed significantly in salami film was used in paragraph 4.
Checked for this overview: The point that bitterness became excessive at high concentrations of essential oil in cream was used in paragraph 4.
Follow the connections
rosemary →— sensory attribute→ bitterness →can be measured separately …→ astringency
Structured claims — open a section to read each claim's confidence, evidence and limits
Composition and content (1)
Scope: The table of a review (a summary of Bayer et al. and Zaikin et al.). The entry common to rosemary and sage.
Note: This is a review's table, and we have not confirmed the original sensory or receptor experiments. The bitter taste receptor column is 'unknown', and no receptor activation is shown. It cannot be said that the bitterness of rosemary extract is mainly due to carnosic acid. Nouska 2023 gives the same component as the reason for a bitterness conjecture but does not verify it.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_bitterness_attributed_to→ (the claim sentence above)Sensory (7)
Scope: Meatballs and hamburger patties made from ground pork. Rosemary ethanol extract at 0.05%. Trained panel of 8.
Note: The composition of the extract (carnosic acid and so on) was not quantified in the text. The bitterness score is on a 0 to 10 line scale. The authors state that the stronger bitterness of the thyme extract than the rosemary one may be due to a difference in phenol content. This is a result at a single concentration of 0.05% and cannot be extended to other concentrations or other foods.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Cold-pressed flaxseed oil (Olivin variety). Rosemary extract (commercial liquid product) at 0.05%. Stored at 25°C and 5°C. Trained panel of 11.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Wheat bread. Solid post-distillation residue of rosemary and other herbs replacing 1% and 2% of the flour. 15 trained assessors.
Note: The sample is not the rosemary leaf itself but the residue left after essential oil was extracted by steam distillation, and it has been through baking. The scores are in Figure 7, and the text has only a sentence on the ranking. The authors give as the reason for the bitterness conjecture that the bitter diterpenes carnosol and carnosic acid are abundant, and they did not test this.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Jelly candy (containing oligosaccharide, inulin and stevia). 2 aqueous rosemary extracts (RE74 and RE146) added at unsupplemented, low, medium and high levels. Trained panel of 15.
Note: Stevia has a strong bitter aftertaste, and the authors state that this may have masked differences in bitterness. This does not mean the extract has no bitterness (the authors write that the extract is bitter but the bitterness of the candy did not increase). The extract is an aqueous extract obtained from a distillation byproduct, not the rosemary leaf used as a spice. It cannot be said that astringency was significantly higher than the unsupplemented candy (the individual comparison did not show a significant difference).
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Olive oil (Aayrouni variety). Flavored with fresh, dried and essential oil of rosemary. Stored for 0, 3 and 6 months. Trained panel of 6.
Note: Olive oil itself has bitterness (3.76 to 3.31 in the unsupplemented oil), so the bitterness derived from rosemary cannot be separated out. There were 6 assessors (from the description of methods). The meaning of n in the table is not asserted.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Oat and buckwheat cookies. Samples with 5 Lamiaceae herbs added and an unsupplemented control. Trained panel of 7.
Note: The bitter aftertaste scores are not given by herb in the text (Figure 1a only). The results are written as a trend across the herbs, and no value for rosemary alone was taken. Buckwheat itself is a material with bitterness, and the reduction in bitterness is a result relative to the bitterness of the control. Use it only within the range that the herbs did not add bitterness. It is buckwheat, not rosemary, that is the base of the bitterness, so it should not be weighted heavily as independent evidence for the bitterness of rosemary. It is the same experiment as on the sage page.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Salami slices. Samples wrapped for 30 days and 90 days in whey protein film containing rosemary extract, and samples in control film. Tasting panel of 12 (1 to 5 intensity scale).
Note: The panel was not trained experts but 12 consumers selected through an online questionnaire (the authors also state that an evaluation by a larger trained panel is needed). The rosemary was extract that migrated from the film, not used as a spice, and the amount is unknown. The values in Table 3 were extracted and copied from the Europe PMC XML.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_response→ (the claim sentence above)How processing and cooking change it (3)
Scope: Fermented thick cream. Rosemary essential oil at 0.068%, 0.13%, 0.24% and 0.34%. Panel of 20 (10 trained industry experts and 10 general consumers).
Note: The sensory evaluation is described only in the sentences of the text; the text gives no individual bitterness score, and the bitterness item and values in Figure 2 were not confirmed (the saved XML contains no image, and the figure legend describes satisfaction). The text's statement that bitterness and other attributes became excessive at 0.24% and 0.34% is retained. The panel had 20 members, half trained and half general. It does not state what in the rosemary essential oil the bitterness comes from. Essential oil differs in composition from extract.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_perceived_bitterness_affected_by→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: An explanatory article in the Journal of Cookery Science of Japan (suggestions for enjoying herbal tea). Thyme, rosemary and sage are given as examples.
Note: This is a suggestion in an explanatory article, not the result of an experiment. The original also touches on medicinal effects, but this laboratory does not adopt them as a claim. There is no measurement of bitterness intensity.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_perceived_bitterness_suppressed_by→ (the claim sentence above)Scope: Descriptions by researchers of the taste of rosemary extract powder for food use (water-soluble and fat-soluble), and the criterion for off-flavor when put into food.
Note: The description is a sentence in the methods section of a paper, not a numerical evaluation by a panel. There are several papers from the same research group (Murcia), and they are not independent sources. It is a powder of extract, not the rosemary leaf itself. The 3 sources of evidence (Martínez-Tomé 2022, Cedeño-Pinos 2020 and 2023) are from the same research group and are not independent of each other.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_attribute→ sensation-bitterCulture (1)
Scope: Descriptions of the taste of rosemary stated in a Japanese review and in a household spice product description (a mildly bitter flavor; a flavor with pronounced mild bitterness).
Note: These are descriptions, not measurements of intensity. The taste descriptions in the review's table come from books (Kosai et al. 2008; Tabei 2000). The same table of the review states that rosemary has a component (cineole) that activates TRPM8, the receptor for cooling sensation, but that concerns cooling, not bitterness.
Show data
spice-rosemary —has_sensory_attribute→ sensation-bitter