palatability (medicinal product)
concept / concept-palatability
服用受容性(パラタビリティ)
Overall acceptability of an oral medicine in relation to smell, taste, aftertaste, and texture (EMA/CHMP/QWP/805880/2012 Rev. 2). WHO TRS 970 Annex 5 adds the dose volume or size to the same construct.
On this page (6 sections)
Reading the bitterness
Palatability describes overall acceptability of an oral medicine in terms of smell, taste, aftertaste, and mouthfeel, as defined by the EMA guideline EMA/CHMP/QWP/805880/2012 Rev. 2. WHO Technical Report Series 970, Annex 5, uses the same idea and also includes dose volume or dosage-form size in assessment. Bitterness is one taste factor affecting acceptability, and research measuring or moderating pharmaceutical bitterness is often ultimately assessed within this palatability framework.
The EU guideline for developing pediatric medicines says information on an active ingredient's palatability should be obtained early, from a dedicated adult panel or existing literature, for example. Unless there is a particular reason otherwise, the pediatric formulation itself should have satisfactory taste and mouthfeel without mixing it with food or drink. The same guideline warns against making pediatric formulations too attractive, like candy, because this is known to raise the incidence of accidental poisoning.
WHO and EMA both state that palatability strongly affects patient acceptability and, through it, adherence to medication. The WHO annex says palatability can be decisive for adherence and that the active ingredient's taste can influence dosage-form choice and design, including taste-masking components. In interviews with 172 children aged 3–10 and 130 mothers in Philadelphia, 89 responding children (58.2%) described having refused medication; among 86 who gave a reason, 73 (84.9%) cited taste or flavor, whereas only 7 (8.1%) cited swallowing or choking.
The interview study's authors themselves say it is unknown how many actual medication failures are due solely to unpleasant taste and that prospective research is needed to understand individual differences. Regulatory documents repeatedly frame palatability as an important link between bitterness and adherence, but the strength of that link has not been supported by measurement in the materials checked here.
Methodological guidance on sensory evaluation of pharmaceutical formulations identifies confusion between actual bitterness and similar sensations such as sourness and astringency as the most common misuse of terms. It says vocabulary understood by panelists matters for characterizing product flavor accurately. The same guidance says taste is one of the major factors in formulation acceptability when the active ingredient contacts oral taste buds, and cites earlier research indicating that children are more sensitive than adults to bitterness, which is naturally aversive unlike sweetness.
A study of the same orally disintegrating tablet measured overall acceptability (palatability) as well as bitterness. During disintegration, overall palatability VAS scores were 38–46 for formulations comparable to no citric acid, but fell to 26 and 20 with 5% and 10% citric acid, respectively. Despite suppressing bitterness, higher citric-acid concentrations thus worsened overall palatability. After spitting out the tablet, however, formulations with 0.1% and 2.5% citric acid scored 54 and 55 for overall palatability, above the no-additive score of 44.
Sources for this overview
Checked for this overview: Checked the definitions of palatability and the attributes assessed. / Checked the advice to obtain palatability information early and the warning against candy-like appeal. / Checked the EMA position on effects on acceptability and adherence.
Checked for this overview: Checked the WHO position that palatability can be decisive for adherence.
Children's perceptions about medicines: individual differences and taste
Checked for this overview: Checked actual counts for experience of refusing medication and reasons given. / Checked the authors' own limitation that the size of taste's contribution was unmeasured.
A Guide to Best Practice in Sensory Analysis of Pharmaceutical Formulations
Checked for this overview: Statement that confusion of bitterness with sourness or astringency is most common. / Earlier research cited as showing greater bitterness sensitivity in children than adults.
Citric Acid Suppresses the Bitter Taste of Olopatadine Hydrochloride Orally Disintegrating Tablets
Checked for this overview: The reversed relationship between citric-acid concentration and overall palatability.
Structured claims — open a section to read each claim's confidence, evidence and limits
Sensory (3)
Scope: Layer: literature (methodological guidance).
Show data
concept-palatability —has_perceived_bitterness_associated_with→ "In sensory evaluation of pharmaceutical formulations, confusion between actual bitterness and similar sensations such as sourness and astringency is described as the most common misuse of terms. Selecting vocabulary that panelists understand and that best characterizes product flavor is considered important."Scope: Layer: literature (methodological guidance).
Note: A review statement citing earlier research (secondary citation).
Show data
concept-palatability —has_perceived_bitterness_associated_with→ "For dosage forms in which the active ingredient can contact taste buds in the mouth, taste is one major determinant of acceptability, especially for children. Children are more sensitive than adults to bitterness, which is inherently aversive unlike sweetness."Scope: Layer: food (orally disintegrating pharmaceutical tablet). Human VAS sensory trial.
Show data
concept-palatability —has_perceived_bitterness_associated_with→ "In orally disintegrating tablets containing a bitter drug, 5% and 10% citric acid lowered overall palatability VAS scores during disintegration to 26 and 20, below the no-additive-comparable 38–46 range. Thus, despite suppressing bitterness, high citric-acid concentrations worsened overall palatability. After spitting out, overall scores for 0.1% and 2.5% citric acid were 54 and 55, above the no-additive score of 44."Safety and regulation (2)
Scope: European Union. The Palatability section of EMA/CHMP/QWP/805880/2012 Rev. 2 (a guideline effective 2014-02-15)
Note: A requirement in the application dossier, not a sensory measurement. The same guideline warns that a pediatric formulation must not resemble candy, because this is known to increase accidental poisoning.
Show data
concept-palatability —must_be_characterised_and_justified_in_eu_paediatric_dossiers→ "Information on the palatability of the active substance should be obtained early, for example from a dedicated adult panel or from the literature. Unless otherwise justified, the palatability of a pediatric formulation should be satisfactory on its own -- without being mixed into food or drink."Scope: Section 3.2 of WHO TRS 970 Annex 5 and Section 10 of EMA/CHMP/QWP/805880/2012 Rev. 2. In both cases, a position statement within a guidance document that reports no effect size
Note: This claim concerns what the 2 official documents themselves state. Neither document quantifies taste's contribution to non-adherence. See the limited evidence from Mennella 2015.
Show data
concept-palatability —is_stated_by_who_and_ema_to_materially_affect→ "Patient acceptability, and, through it, adherence for oral pediatric medicines"