日本語版

Topic hub — 2026-09-08

Sansai and seasonal bitterness

Among sansai (Japanese wild spring greens), sources that actually name bitterness itself are, in practice, almost limited to fukinoto (Petasites japonicus flower bud) and yomogi (Artemisia princeps). In fukinoto, the bitter compounds bakkenolide B, isopetasin, and fukinone have been isolated, while a report found that almost none of the bitterness transferred when extracted with hot water or dilute alcohol — so how much household pretreatment such as blanching and soaking in water actually moves the bitterness itself has, in fact, not been measured. The saying "pile bitterness onto the spring plate" is repeatedly introduced by food-culture web media, but even after tracing the Meiji-era passage usually cited as its origin back to the original text, it could not be confirmed down to the last character. Sources describe shidoke and hassaku individually as having a slight bitterness, but for many other sansai — including warabi (Pteridium aquilinum, bracken), zenmai (Osmunda japonica), and yamaudo (Aralia cordata) — no source naming bitterness has yet been connected. Here, what has been confirmed and what has not yet been measured are laid out side by side, kept separate.

On this page (12 sections)
  1. What this page establishes
  2. Pile bitterness onto the spring plate — where the saying comes from
  3. Which sansai are bitter — what the sources actually name
  4. Fukinoto and yomogi — compounds confirmed as bitter
  5. Does aku removal move the bitterness — what has not been measured
  6. Outside spring — autumn in the hills, and spring next door
  7. The prep ledger and what to check in the kitchen
  8. Frequently asked
  9. What is not known
  10. Read in the encyclopedia
  11. Go deeper in the research notes
  12. Source ledger
↑

What this page establishes

Pile bitterness onto the spring plate — where the saying comes from

The saying "pile bitterness onto the spring plate" is repeatedly introduced in food-culture columns and health-focused web media as a line meaning that people should eat bitter sansai and spring vegetables in spring.

"Fill the spring plate with bitterness" (Japanese saying) is presented as: A saying repeatedly presented by several food-culture and health web media as a "proverb" urging people to eat bitter foods (mainly sansai and spring vegetables) in springcontextual

Scope: Japanese-language web media (food-culture and health columns)

Presents it, saying: "Many of you have probably heard the proverb 'Pile bitterness onto the spring plate.'"
Limitations: Inclusion in dictionaries of classical sayings and proverbs has not been confirmed.
Source: 春は苦味をたのしむ|日本の季節を楽しむ暮らし (暦生活編集部) · full text checked
Presents it, saying: "There is a proverb, 'Pile bitterness onto the spring plate.'"
Limitations: As above.
Source: 【春の皿には苦味を盛れ】春の味覚を楽しめる季節です。 (職人.comブログ編集部) · full text checked
Show dataconcept-spring-bitter-plate-saying —is_presented_as→ "A saying repeatedly presented by several food-culture and health web media as a "proverb" urging people to eat bitter foods (mainly sansai and spring vegetables) in spring"
claim: clm-spring-bitter-saying-media-presented / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02

Its origin is widely attributed to a passage in a book by Ishizuka Sagen, a Meiji-era physician and pharmacist. However, sources disagree on the final word — "oil" in some, "fat" in others — so while several media outlets tell the same origin story, the details do not line up.

"Fill the spring plate with bitterness" (Japanese saying) — origin narrative as told: Several food-culture and health web media, along with the official website of Fukui City, explain that it originates from a passage in Ishizuka Sagen's book Shokumotsu Yōjōhō (1898), a Meiji-era physician and pharmacist: "spring bitterness, vinegared dishes in summer, pungent flavor in autumn, and oil (or, depending on the source, 'fat') in winter — eat with this understanding"contextual

Scope: The attribution theory pointing to Ishizuka Sagen's Shokumotsu Yōjōhō (1898)

"Ishizuka Sagen's book Shokumotsu Yōjōhō states: 'Spring bitterness, vinegared dishes in summer, pungent flavor in autumn, and oil — eat with this understanding.' ..."
Limitations: The page number in the original book has not been confirmed. It may be a secondhand citation.
Source: 【春の皿には苦味を盛れ】春の味覚を楽しめる季節です。 (職人.comブログ編集部) · full text checked
"Spring bitterness, vinegared dishes in summer, pungent flavor in autumn, and fat — eat with this understanding"
Limitations: Even for the same passage, the wording differs between sources — for example "oil" versus "fat." The page number in the original book has not been confirmed.
Source: 石塚左玄の紹介(食育) (福井市) · full text checked
Context: Shokumotsu Yōjōhō carries the bibliographic record: published by Hakubunkan in the 1st month of Meiji 31 (1898); 211 pages; 22 cm. However, this reference answer itself is an inquiry into the first recorded use of the word "shokuiku" (food education), and it does not confirm the location of the "spring bitterness" passage.
Limitations: Whether this passage is actually contained in the book cannot be confirmed from this reference answer.
Source: 「食育」という言葉の初出といわれる石塚左玄『食物養生法』を探している。 (国立国会図書館 レファレンス協同データベース) · full text checked
Limits: While using the same expression "Pile bitterness onto the spring plate" as a headline, the body text makes no mention of Ishizuka Sagen or Shokumotsu Yōjōhō, and gives only the explanation that it "mainly refers to spring vegetables."
Limitations: This article alone can neither confirm nor deny the Ishizuka Sagen origin theory, but it shows that the explanation of this saying's origin is not uniform across media.
Source: 「春の皿には苦味を盛れ」の意味とは? (スポーツナビコラム編集部) · full text checked
Show dataconcept-spring-bitter-plate-saying —has_historical_origin_narrative→ "Several food-culture and health web media, along with the official website of Fukui City, explain that it originates from a passage in Ishizuka Sagen's book Shokumotsu Yōjōhō (1898), a Meiji-era physician and pharmacist: "spring bitterness, vinegared dishes in summer, pungent flavor in autumn, and oil (or, depending on the source, 'fat') in winter — eat with this understanding""
claim: clm-spring-bitter-saying-ishizuka-origin / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02

Checking the poetry collection this origin theory points to directly, in high-resolution images from the National Diet Library Digital Collections, the phrase "spring bitterness" and a verse lining up the seasons were indeed found on the relevant page — but a sentence containing the word assigned to winter could not be read through in the time available. The result neither confirms nor overturns the origin theory.

"Fill the spring plate with bitterness" (Japanese saying) is documented in Image 45 of the upper volume of Shokuyō Dōka Zokukai (Shokuyō Shinbunsha, 1906) — a collection of poems composed by Ishizuka Sagen with a vernacular commentary added by Uji Harukazu (pen name Konohanaen) — contains one poem linking the seasons to food-based regimen. The commentary text presents one phrase of the poem in quotation marks as "spring bitterness," and goes on to explain the poem's intent using the words "vinegared things in summer," "pungent flavor in autumn," and a phrase corresponding to "eat with this understanding."contextual

Scope: Shokuyō Dōka Zokukai, upper volume, image 45 (National Diet Library Digital Collections, pid 836944)

In the commentary text, the phrase "spring bitterness" appears in quotation marks, and within the same paragraph the words "vinegared things in summer" and "pungent flavor in autumn," a reference to the four seasons of spring, summer, autumn, and winter together with four flavors including salty, and a phrase corresponding to "eat with this understanding" can be confirmed. The specific sentence containing the word assigned to winter (whether "oil" or "fat") could not be read with certainty from the high-resolution image within the time available for this survey.
Limitations: A word-for-word check could not be made of the specific location containing the single word assigned to winter ("oil" / "fat"). The character corresponding to "gatten" (understanding) in the commentary text also appears in a variant form, so it could not be fixed to a standard form. Only the area around image 45 was read out of the book's 65 images in total, and no confirmed transcription or modern-language rendering of the whole poem was made. The integrator also visually confirmed, in the high-resolution image of image 45, each of the phrases "'spring bitterness' appears," "eat with this understanding," "vinegared things in summer," "the four seasons of spring, summer, autumn ... winter," and "the four flavors including salty." The single word assigned to winter remains unconfirmed.
Source: 食養道歌俗解 上巻 (食養叢書 ; 第1編) (石塚左玄 詠, 莵道春千代(木花園) 解, 1906) · full text checked
Show dataconcept-spring-bitter-plate-saying —is_documented_in→ "Image 45 of the upper volume of Shokuyō Dōka Zokukai (Shokuyō Shinbunsha, 1906) — a collection of poems composed by Ishizuka Sagen with a vernacular commentary added by Uji Harukazu (pen name Konohanaen) — contains one poem linking the seasons to food-based regimen. The commentary text presents one phrase of the poem in quotation marks as "spring bitterness," and goes on to explain the poem's intent using the words "vinegared things in summer," "pungent flavor in autumn," and a phrase corresponding to "eat with this understanding.""
claim: clm-spring-bitter-saying-doka-zokukai-koma45 / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02

As for sansai themselves being recorded together with bitterness, there is the haiku kigo (season word). Fukinoto is entered as a kigo for early spring, and tara-no-me (Aralia elata shoot) as a kigo for mid-spring, and both entries mention bitterness.

fukinoto (butterbur flower bud) — cultural role: A kigo (season word) for early spring in haiku. Its related child-kigo include "fuki no me," "fuki no hana," and "fuki no shūtome," and the Kigosai Saijiki explains that it is "valued for its distinctive fragrance and slightly bitter flavor." It records as an example verse Sugita Hisajo's haiku "horonigaki koi no aji nari fuki no tō" (a slightly bitter taste of love, this fukinoto).contextual

Scope: Kigosai Saijiki

Explains: "In early spring, before new leaves emerge, an egg-shaped green flower stalk rises from the rhizome. The flower stalk is wrapped in several large scale-like leaves, and its distinctive fragrance and slightly bitter flavor are valued." It classifies the season as early spring, gives "fuki no me," "fuki no hana," and "fuki no shūtome" as related child-kigo, and records as an example verse Sugita Hisajo's haiku "horonigaki koi no aji nari fuki no tō" (a slightly bitter taste of love, this fukinoto).
Limitations: The source of the example verse (which edition and page of the haiku collection) has not been confirmed.
Source: 蕗の薹(ふきのとう、ふきのたう) 初春 (きごさい歳時記編集部) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-fukinoto —has_cultural_role_of→ "A kigo (season word) for early spring in haiku. Its related child-kigo include "fuki no me," "fuki no hana," and "fuki no shūtome," and the Kigosai Saijiki explains that it is "valued for its distinctive fragrance and slightly bitter flavor." It records as an example verse Sugita Hisajo's haiku "horonigaki koi no aji nari fuki no tō" (a slightly bitter taste of love, this fukinoto)."
claim: clm-fukinoto-haiku-kigo / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02
tara-no-me (Aralia elata shoot) — cultural role: A kigo for mid-spring in haiku. The Kigosai Saijiki explains that "the slightly bitter young shoot is a representative sansai of early spring." It records as an example verse Issa's haiku "tara no me no toge darake demo kuwarekeri" (even thorn-covered, the tara-no-me shoot gets eaten) from Hachiban Nikki (Eighth Diary).contextual

Scope: Kigosai Saijiki

Classifies the season as mid-spring and explains that "the slightly bitter young shoot is a representative sansai of early spring." It records Issa's haiku "tara no me no toge darake demo kuwarekeri" (even thorn-covered, the tara-no-me shoot gets eaten), from Hachiban Nikki (Eighth Diary), as the example verse.
Limitations: The edition and page of Hachiban Nikki have not been confirmed.
Source: たらの芽(たらのめ)仲春 (きごさい歳時記編集部) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-taranome —has_cultural_role_of→ "A kigo for mid-spring in haiku. The Kigosai Saijiki explains that "the slightly bitter young shoot is a representative sansai of early spring." It records as an example verse Issa's haiku "tara no me no toge darake demo kuwarekeri" (even thorn-covered, the tara-no-me shoot gets eaten) from Hachiban Nikki (Eighth Diary)."
claim: clm-taranome-haiku-kigo / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02

There is another, separate lineage of sayings about bitterness. "Ryoyaku wa kuchi ni nigashi" (good medicine is bitter in the mouth) has both a dictionary definition and a cited source, and the classical original text given as its source can be checked directly. Unlike the spring-plate saying, this one is easier to cross-check across sources for the word's history.

"Good medicine is bitter in the mouth" (Japanese proverb) is defined in a dictionary as "A well-working medicine is bitter and hard to swallow. A metaphor meaning that good advice is painful to hear but is for one's own good."contextual

Scope: Digital Daijisen dictionary definition of "ryoyaku wa kuchi ni nigashi" (good medicine is bitter in the mouth), as posted on Kotobank

Note: This is recorded not as a claim about the real effectiveness of medicine, but as the dictionary's definition of the saying itself.

Verbatim: "A well-working medicine is bitter and hard to swallow. A metaphor meaning that good advice is painful to hear but is for one's own good."
Limitations: The print original (Shogakukan's Digital Daijisen) itself was not checked directly; only the reprint on Kotobank was consulted.
Source: 良薬は口に苦し · full text checked
Show dataconcept-proverb-ryoyaku-kuchi-ni-nigashi —is_defined_in_dictionary_as→ ""A well-working medicine is bitter and hard to swallow. A metaphor meaning that good advice is painful to hear but is for one's own good.""
claim: clm-w59a-daijisen-ryoyaku-def / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-04
"Good medicine is bitter in the mouth" (Japanese proverb) — etymology of the name: "From the 'Liu Ben' chapter of Kongzi Jiayu"contextual

Scope: Digital Daijisen dictionary's source note for "ryoyaku wa kuchi ni nigashi," as posted on Kotobank

Note: The source attribution as given by the dictionary. The original text of Kongzi Jiayu itself has not been confirmed.

Verbatim: "From the 'Liu Ben' chapter of Kongzi Jiayu"
Limitations: The original text of Kongzi Jiayu itself has not been confirmed. Only the dictionary's source attribution is available.
Source: 良薬は口に苦し · full text checked
Show dataconcept-proverb-ryoyaku-kuchi-ni-nigashi —has_name_etymology→ ""From the 'Liu Ben' chapter of Kongzi Jiayu""
claim: clm-w59a-daijisen-ryoyaku-origin / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-04
"Good medicine is bitter in the mouth" (Japanese proverb) is documented in Confucius said (Kongzi yue): 「藥酒苦於口而利於病,忠言逆於耳而利於行。」 (in translation: "Medicinal wine is bitter to the mouth but benefits the illness; honest words go against the ear but benefit conduct.")contextual

Scope: Chinese Text Project (ctext.org), Kongzi Jiayu, "Liu Ben," chapter 2

Note: The original wording is 「藥酒苦於口」 (medicinal wine is bitter to the mouth), not the exact phrase 「良藥苦口」 (good medicine is bitter to the mouth). It is recorded as a candidate classical source for the Japanese proverb "ryoyaku wa kuchi ni nigashi" (good medicine is bitter in the mouth), with the difference in wording made explicit.

Verbatim: 「藥酒苦於口而利於病,忠言逆於耳而利於行。」 (in translation: "Medicinal wine is bitter to the mouth but benefits the illness; honest words go against the ear but benefit conduct.")
Limitations: The wording of the original is 「藥酒苦於口」 (medicinal wine is bitter to the mouth), not 「良藥苦口」 (good medicine is bitter to the mouth). Its agreement with the Japanese proverb is limited to matching intent, not exact wording.
Show dataconcept-proverb-ryoyaku-kuchi-ni-nigashi —is_documented_in→ "Confucius said (Kongzi yue): 「藥酒苦於口而利於病,忠言逆於耳而利於行。」 (in translation: "Medicinal wine is bitter to the mouth but benefits the illness; honest words go against the ear but benefit conduct.")"
claim: clm-w59b-liang-yao-ku-yu-kou / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-04

Which sansai are bitter — what the sources actually name

For shidoke (momijigasa, Parasenecio delphiniifolius), a description naming a slight bitterness can be found on farm-direct and ingredient-introduction sites.

Japonicalia delphiniifolia — sensory attribute: A fragrance resembling fuki, and a slight bitternesscontextual

Scope: Descriptions on 2 farm-direct and ingredient-introduction websites

Shidoke (momijigasa) is presented as having a slight bitterness and being typically eaten as ohitashi or tempura; it is described as having a fragrance resembling fuki, leaves with a soft texture and strong flavor, and a stem that is tender yet has some bite.
Limitations: A commercial vegetable-introduction blog, not an academic or official source. No detailed record of harvesting location, season, or cultivar.
Source: しどけ(モミジガサ) その他の野菜 味の感想や特徴など (やさいナビ編集部, 2015) · full text checked
Described as: "characterized by a distinctive fragrance, slight bitterness, and texture, an ingredient somewhat geared toward adult palates" and "because of these characteristics, opinions are divided, but it is a sansai that many people become hooked on."
Limitations: A description by an individual commercial site operator, not peer-reviewed. Statements about nutrition or purported effects are not adopted here.
Source: しどけの栄養と食べ方!効果的な調理法とレシピを覚えよう (農園カフェ「Daichi & keats」, 2021) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-shidoke —has_sensory_attribute→ "A fragrance resembling fuki, and a slight bitterness"
claim: clm-jp-shidoke-horonigai / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-02

Not a sansai but a citrus, hassaku (Citrus hassaku) is also recorded in sources as a food spoken of for bitterness in spring. It is presented as a citrus native to Japan, with descriptions of both a faint bitterness within its sweet-tartness and a distinctive slight bitterness in its juice.

Hassaku — historical origin: A citrus native to Japan, described as a mid-to-late-season citrus with a crisp texture and a faint bitterness within its sweet-tartness.contextual

Scope: The same page.

Describes it: "Hassaku is a citrus native to Japan, a mid-to-late-season citrus characterized by a crisp texture and a faint bitterness within its sweet-tartness."
Source: わかやま食材テロワール「八朔(はっさく)」 (和歌山県 農林水産部 農林水産政策局 食品流通課) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-hassaku —has_historical_origin→ "A citrus native to Japan, described as a mid-to-late-season citrus with a crisp texture and a faint bitterness within its sweet-tartness."
claim: clm-hassaku-japan-native-citrus / type: taxonomy / updated: 2026-09-02
Hassaku is presented as: "The juice has a moderate sweetness and acidity, characterized by a distinctive slight bitterness"observation

Scope: Product description on the official page of Ito Farm (Wakayama Prefecture), a business-use seller of hassaku juice

Note: The same page also explains a production method in which only the flesh is gently squeezed with a bowl-shaped device, so that components from the outer and inner peel are not included in the juice. The relationship between this peel-excluding method and the source of the described slight bitterness (whether from the flesh itself or from residual peel) is not made explicit on the page.

Describes hassaku juice as "having a moderate sweetness and acidity, characterized by a distinctive slight bitterness," and also records a production method in which only the flesh is gently squeezed with a bowl-shaped device so that components from the outer and inner peel are not included in the juice.
Limitations: The relationship between the peel-excluding production method and the source of the described slight bitterness (whether from the flesh itself or from residual peel) is not made explicit on the page.
Source: 八朔(はっさく)果汁の業務用・仕入れ・卸ページ (株式会社伊藤農園) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-hassaku —is_presented_as→ ""The juice has a moderate sweetness and acidity, characterized by a distinctive slight bitterness""
claim: clm-w51-hassaku-presented / type: sensory / updated: 2026-09-03

On the other hand, for warabi (Pteridium aquilinum, bracken), zenmai (Osmunda japonica), kogomi (Matteuccia struthiopteris, ostrich fern), ukogi (Eleutherococcus sieboldianus), itadori (Reynoutria japonica, Japanese knotweed), tsuwabuki (Farfugium japonicum), and yamaudo (Aralia cordata), no source naming bitterness has yet been connected.warabi (bracken),zenmai (Osmunda japonica),kogomi (ostrich fern),ukogi (Eleutherococcus),itadori (Japanese knotweed),tsuwabuki, andyamaudo (Aralia cordata) all have encyclopedia entries, but no body text yet. A name being listed as a sansai and its bitterness being confirmed by a source are treated here as two separate matters.

Fukinoto and yomogi — compounds confirmed as bitter

For fukinoto, a compound has been isolated as the principal bitter constituent: a white crystalline solid obtained by separating an organic-solvent extract on alumina, initially known under a different name before being renamed.

fukinoto (butterbur flower bud) — principal bitter compound: bakkenolide Bsupported

Scope: Air-dried fukinoto collected around Sendai and studied by a group at Tohoku College of Pharmacy (1960s-1972)

Note: After the author initially named it Petasinolide, it was renamed Bakkenolide-B in consultation with Abe and Kitahara to avoid a name conflict with a European fuki constituent. It is the same substance as Naya et al.'s Fukinolide. Based on an expository article from a single research group; the primary experimental paper has not been read.

The organic-solvent extract was chromatographed on alumina, yielding a white crystalline compound, mp 101-102 C, isolated as the principal bitter constituent. It was initially named Petasinolide and later renamed Bakkenolide-B. Naya's fukinolide is the same substance, a sesquiterpene lactone diol ester making up 0.1% of the air-dried plant.
Limitations: This is an expository article; the primary experimental paper has not been read. There is no record of the sensory evaluation method or intensity of the bitterness.
Source: フキノトウの成分研究から(研究室) (栗原藤三郎, 1972) · full text checked
Context: The review reproduces the report by Shibata and Shimizu, identifying bakkenolide B along with bakkenolide A, fukinone, and isopetasin as the principal terpenoids of fuki and fukinoto, and identifying bakkenolide B as the active substance for yeast growth recovery. Nowhere in the review is bitterness itself discussed.
Limitations: A review centered on functional properties; the contribution of the constituents to bitterness is outside its subject.
Show dataingredient-fukinoto —has_principal_bitter_compound→ compound-bakkenolide-b
claim: clm-fukinoto-bitter-bakkenolide-b / type: composition / updated: 2026-08-30

The same study also obtained a bitter-described crystal and an oily substance, respectively, from the remaining fraction after the principal constituent was removed.

fukinoto (butterbur flower bud) contains Isopetasin (melting point 95 C, 0.09% of the air-dried plant, bitter) and fukinone (oily, 0.2% yield by vacuum distillation, bitter)supported

Scope: The same air-dried fukinoto material used for the isolation of Bakkenolide-B

Note: Neither the intensity, threshold, nor contribution ratio of the bitterness is recorded — only a qualitative description that it possesses bitterness. An antimicrobial assay is recorded as showing that none of the bitter substances exhibited antimicrobial activity.

From the filtrate after removing bakkenolide B, white crystals of isopetasine (mp 95 C) were obtained, described as bitter, at a content of 0.09%. Vacuum distillation of the residue gave fukinone at a yield of 0.2%, an oily substance described as exhibiting bitterness.
Limitations: Only a qualitative description, with no threshold or contribution ratio. The spelling "isopetasine" is kept as in the original text (the same substance as isopetasin).
Source: フキノトウの成分研究から(研究室) (栗原藤三郎, 1972) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-fukinoto —contains→ "Isopetasin (melting point 95 C, 0.09% of the air-dried plant, bitter) and fukinone (oily, 0.2% yield by vacuum distillation, bitter)"
claim: clm-fukinoto-other-bitter-compounds / type: composition / updated: 2026-08-30

In yomogi, sesquiterpene compounds isolated from a fraction of the aerial parts have been reported to show a stronger bitterness than caffeine (a finding reported within the scope of the abstract).

yomogi greens is documented as having 2 sesquiterpene compounds isolated from an activity-guided fractionation of the aerial parts (1α,6α,8α-trihydroxy-5α,7βH-guaia-3,9,11(13)-trien-12-oic acid, and artecalin) were about 50 times more bitter than caffeine, showing a bitterness comparable to quinine hydrochloride.preliminary

Scope: Layer: solution. Extract and fractions of the aerial parts of Artemisia princeps Pamp., with the bitter constituents isolated by activity-guided fractionation.

Records: "50 times bitterer than caffeine and had similar bitterness to quinine HCl." Reports that the bitter constituents were concentrated in the flavonoid-rich fraction.
Limitations: The bitterness intensity comparison is a relative evaluation against caffeine and quinine hydrochloride; details such as absolute concentration and panel size have not been confirmed at the level of the text summary.
Source: Identification of bitter components from Artemisia princeps Pamp. (Park Hee-Jung; Cho Jin-Gyeong; Baek Yoon-Su; Seo Kyeong-Hwa; Kim Su-Yeon; Choi Myung-Sook; Lee Kyung-Tae; Jeong Tae-Sook; Chung Hae-Gon; Kang Eun-Gyeong; Baek Nam-In, 2016) · abstract checked
Show dataingredient-yomogi —is_documented_as_having→ "2 sesquiterpene compounds isolated from an activity-guided fractionation of the aerial parts (1α,6α,8α-trihydroxy-5α,7βH-guaia-3,9,11(13)-trien-12-oic acid, and artecalin) were about 50 times more bitter than caffeine, showing a bitterness comparable to quinine hydrochloride."
claim: clm-w72b1-yomogi-sesquiterpenes-more-bitter-than-caffeine / type: composition / updated: 2026-09-08

In the same yomogi study, two flavonoids known for their high content — eupatilin and jaceosidin — showed no confirmed bitterness. High content and strong bitterness do not line up even within the same plant.

yomogi greens is documented as having Eupatilin and jaceosidin, the major bioactive constituents of Artemisia princeps, both showed no bitterness.preliminary

Scope: Layer: solution. Extract and fractions of the aerial parts of Artemisia princeps Pamp., with the bitter constituents isolated by activity-guided fractionation.

Note: A finding that negatively identifies major constituents as not being the main cause of bitterness. A separate statement from the same source.

"Neither eupatilin nor jaceosidin, the major active components of A. princeps, showed any bitterness."
Limitations: Details of the criteria used to judge the absence of bitterness (detection limit, panel method) have not been confirmed at the summary stage.
Source: Identification of bitter components from Artemisia princeps Pamp. (Park Hee-Jung; Cho Jin-Gyeong; Baek Yoon-Su; Seo Kyeong-Hwa; Kim Su-Yeon; Choi Myung-Sook; Lee Kyung-Tae; Jeong Tae-Sook; Chung Hae-Gon; Kang Eun-Gyeong; Baek Nam-In, 2016) · abstract checked
Show dataingredient-yomogi —is_documented_as_having→ "Eupatilin and jaceosidin, the major bioactive constituents of Artemisia princeps, both showed no bitterness."
claim: clm-w72b1-yomogi-eupatilin-jaceosidin-not-bitter / type: composition / updated: 2026-09-08

Does aku removal move the bitterness — what has not been measured

The study that isolated fukinoto's bitter compounds first questioned the extraction method itself. Almost no bitterness transferred with hot water or dilute alcohol, and the author abandoned the hypothesis that had been dominant until then, switching to a different extraction method.

fukinoto (butterbur flower bud) — bitterness is poorly extracted by: Almost no bitterness transfers into hot-water extracts or dilute-alcohol extracts. The author abandoned the bitter-glycoside hypothesis and used organic-solvent extraction instead.supported

Scope: An extraction experiment on fukinoto reported by Kurihara (1972)

Because almost no bitterness transferred into hot-water and dilute-alcohol extracts of fukinoto, the author discarded the bitter-glycoside hypothesis that was prevailing at the time and switched to organic-solvent extraction, which yielded the principal bitter constituent.
Limitations: No quantitative data is given. The conditions differ from the bitterness-retention rate after boiling and discarding the water for fresh material.
Source: フキノトウの成分研究から(研究室) (栗原藤三郎, 1972) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-fukinoto —has_bitterness_poorly_extracted_by→ "Almost no bitterness transfers into hot-water extracts or dilute-alcohol extracts. The author abandoned the bitter-glycoside hypothesis and used organic-solvent extraction instead."
claim: clm-fukinoto-bitterness-low-water-transfer / type: processing / updated: 2026-08-30

This extraction experiment did not directly measure how much kitchen-level aku removal — blanching and soaking in water — moves bitterness itself. Looking more broadly, research on how the bitter compounds of plant-based foods change through cooking is summed up, in the closing words of a review, as something that "has hardly been carried out."

aku-nuki (blanch-and-soak treatment) is documented as having The closing words of a 1980 review: "Research on the formation of bitter compounds contained in plant-based foods, and on its prevention, still has much left for the future. In addition, research on how these bitter compounds change through cooking has hardly been carried out."supported

Scope: Layer: literature. The closing statement of a 1980 review of Japanese culinary science (an overview of bitter compounds in food).

Note: A record in which the researcher themselves, as of 1980, wrote about the gap in research directly measuring the relationship between aku removal, other pretreatment, and bitterness.

"The above sets out an overview of the bitter compounds in foods known to date, but research on the formation of bitter compounds contained in plant-based foods, and on its prevention, still has much left for the future. In addition, research on how these bitter compounds change through cooking has hardly been carried out."
Limitations: The author's assessment as of 1980. Whether research has since been done cannot be determined from this source.
Source: 食品の苦味成分 (萩原清和, 1980) · full text checked
Show dataprocess-aku-nuki —is_documented_as_having→ "The closing words of a 1980 review: "Research on the formation of bitter compounds contained in plant-based foods, and on its prevention, still has much left for the future. In addition, research on how these bitter compounds change through cooking has hardly been carried out.""
claim: clm-hagihara-1980-cooking-bitterness-research-gap / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-07

Outside spring — autumn in the hills, and spring next door

So far this page has followed the spring plate. But the same handling — tasting the faint bitterness, adjusting it in preparation — is recorded outside spring as well. Autumn in the hills, and spring in the country next door, placed here on the same scale.

Ginkgo nuts are described as having a distinctive flavour, a gentle sweetness behind a faint bitterness, with a floury texture and a nutty richness once heated.

ginkgo nut — sensory attribute: A distinctive flavor with gentle sweetness behind slight bitterness, developing a fluffy texture and nut-like richness when heated.contextual

Scope: A web article explaining the taste of ginkgo nuts (Wagokoro Gohanchō).

Note: The writer's personal sensory description, not a sensory panel.

The article says 「ほろ苦さの奥に、やさしい甘みがある味」 (in translation: "a taste with gentle sweetness behind slight bitterness"), 「少し苦い?と感じることもありますが、その苦みこそが秋の味わい」 (in translation: "you may find it a little bitter, but that bitterness is the taste of autumn"), and 「ほっくりとした食感とともに、ナッツのようなコクが広がります」 (in translation: "a nut-like richness spreads along with a fluffy texture").
Limitations: The writer's personal sensory description, not a sensory panel.
Source: 銀杏(ぎんなん)はどんな味?苦い?|美味しい食べ方と下処理・旬・栄養・保存方法 (やまだまゆみ(和ごころごはん帖)) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-ginkgo-nut —has_sensory_attribute→ "A distinctive flavor with gentle sweetness behind slight bitterness, developing a fluffy texture and nut-like richness when heated."
claim: clm-aprep-ginkgo-baseline-sensory / type: sensory / updated: 2026-09-13

The bitterness is attributed to alkaloid constituents, but the article names no compound. Set against fukinoto, where the work goes as far as bakkenolide B, this stops one step short of a name.

ginkgo nut — perceived bitterness is associated with: Alkaloid components (the article does not identify specific compounds).contextual

Scope: A web article explaining ginkgo-nut bitterness (Bow!, July 13, 2021).

Note: The article says only 「苦みの正体はアルカロイドという成分」 (in translation: "the source of bitterness is a component called an alkaloid") and provides no identification of particular compounds or quantitative data. Lacking such data, this statement is not connected to a discussion of safety or intake amounts.

It says 「苦みの正体は『アルカロイド』という成分」 (in translation: "the source of bitterness is a component called an alkaloid") and 「銀杏(ぎんなん)の薄皮に苦みを感じる方もいるようです」 (in translation: "some people seem to notice bitterness in the thin skin of ginkgo nuts").
Limitations: No compound-identification or quantitative data are given, and this is not a peer-reviewed source.
Show dataingredient-ginkgo-nut —has_perceived_bitterness_associated_with→ "Alkaloid components (the article does not identify specific compounds)."
claim: clm-aprep-ginkgo-alkaloid-bitterness / type: composition / updated: 2026-09-13

The preparation is written in the same shape as for the spring greens: after removing the inner skin, soak the nuts in water for about a day, as aku removal. No endpoint is given.

ginkgo nut is prepared by: A preparation step of removing the thin skin (inner seed coat) and soaking the kernel in water for about a day for 「アク抜き」 (in translation: "aku removal"), as quoted from Nagano producer information.contextual

Scope: Nagano producer information quoted by the Bow! article.

Note: A secondary quotation in the b-o-w.jp article; the primary source itself was not checked in this investigation. The step is not explicitly described as aiming to weaken bitterness; the source uses only the term 「アク抜き」 (in translation: "aku removal").

Quotes the Nagano information's step 「一日アク抜きします」 (in translation: "we do aku removal for a day") and describes soaking peeled kernels in water for a period.
Limitations: The primary source (the Nagano producer information itself) was not directly checked in this investigation; only a secondary quotation was available.
Show dataingredient-ginkgo-nut —is_prepared_by→ "A preparation step of removing the thin skin (inner seed coat) and soaking the kernel in water for about a day for 「アク抜き」 (in translation: "aku removal"), as quoted from Nagano producer information."
claim: clm-aprep-ginkgo-akunuki-soak / type: culinary / updated: 2026-09-13

There is also a way of covering rather than removing. Deep-frying is named as a method that softens the bitterness.

ginkgo nut — perceived bitterness is suppressed by: Frying in oil as a cooking method.contextual

Scope: A web article on ways to eat ginkgo nuts (Wagokoro Gohanchō).

Note: A description in a cooking web publication rather than a sensory panel. The same article compares several preparation methods, including microwave heating, boiling water, and dry roasting.

States 「揚げると→ほろ苦さがやわらぐ」 (in translation: "frying → the slight bitterness softens").
Limitations: No corroboration from a sensory panel or chemical analysis; one cooking web article.
Source: 銀杏(ぎんなん)はどんな味?苦い?|美味しい食べ方と下処理・旬・栄養・保存方法 (やまだまゆみ(和ごころごはん帖)) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-ginkgo-nut —has_perceived_bitterness_suppressed_by→ "Frying in oil as a cooking method."
claim: clm-aprep-ginkgo-frying-softens-bitterness / type: culinary / updated: 2026-09-13

Akebi peel is an autumn food of the hills with its faint bitterness explicitly named.

akebi peel — sensory attribute: bitternesscontextual

Scope: The expression that the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries' 『うちの郷土料理』 (in translation: "Our Local Cuisine") gives for the flavor of the peel in Yamagata Prefecture

The Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries' Yamagata Prefecture local-cuisine page states that Yamagata Prefecture has a food culture of eating akebi peel, and records its flavor as 「ほろ苦く」 (in translation: "mildly bitter").
Limitations: This is not a source that presents a sensory panel, sample conditions, or measured bitterness-intensity values. The page is an introduction to Yamagata Prefecture's local cuisine and does not represent the peel of every Akebia species or every region.
Source: あけびの味噌詰め焼き/あけびの油焼き 山形県 (農林水産省) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-akebi-peel —has_sensory_attribute→ sensation-bitter
claim: clm-akebi-peel-maff-horonigai / type: sensory / updated: 2026-09-16

And here is something the spring side of this page did not have: an experiment comparing preparations. Among treatments of the peel, the sample heated for 3 minutes with 1% salt added and then soaked in water for 8 hours ranked best by a ranking method.

akebi peel is documented as having In a comparison of peel pretreatments, the sample treated with 1% added salt, heated for 3 minutes, and soaked in water for 8 hours ranked best by the ranking methodpreliminary

Scope: A comparison of akebi peel pretreatments recorded in a publicly available undergraduate thesis abstract from Akita University

Note: The public PDF is an undergraduate thesis abstract and does not give the number of sensory evaluators, statistical testing, or a bitterness scale in detail. The ranking-method result is not treated as identifying a specific optimal condition for bitterness reduction. The body text does not state that the samples were stored frozen.

The public abstract reports that, for akebi peel, 10 samples combining the presence or absence of 3-minute heating and 8-hour water-soaking with additives in the heating water were sensory-evaluated and color-measured, and that the sample treated with 1% added salt, heated for 3 minutes, and soaked in water for 8 hours ranked best by the ranking method.
Limitations: This is an undergraduate thesis abstract, and the number of evaluators, randomization, statistical testing, and a bitterness scale cannot be confirmed from the body text. The ranking-method result cannot be read as a specific optimal condition for bitterness reduction. The sample's plant species, collection site, and storage conditions are also not specified in the body text.
Show dataingredient-akebi-peel —is_documented_as_having→ "In a comparison of peel pretreatments, the sample treated with 1% added salt, heated for 3 minutes, and soaked in water for 8 hours ranked best by the ranking method"
claim: clm-akebi-peel-saltwater-treatment / type: processing / updated: 2026-09-16

The author's summary runs the same way: heating with added salt and soaking in water reduced the bitterness to some degree. What this page has been calling unmeasured on the sansai side has moved one step forward for akebi peel.

akebi peel is documented as having The author's summary that pretreatment by heating with added salt and water-soaking reduced the bitterness to some degreepreliminary

Scope: The description of the peel pretreatment comparison in the general discussion of a publicly available undergraduate thesis abstract from Akita University

Note: This is the summary of an undergraduate thesis abstract, and which treatment is optimal for bitterness reduction, the number of evaluators, a bitterness scale, and statistical testing cannot be confirmed from the body text. The body text does not state that the samples were stored frozen.

In the general discussion, the author sums up that pretreatment by heating with added salt and water-soaking reduced the bitterness of akebi peel to some degree.
Limitations: The general discussion is a passage summing up the comparison results of the treatments and does not identify which condition is optimal for bitterness reduction. In this undergraduate thesis abstract, the number of evaluators, statistical testing, plant species, collection site, and storage conditions are not stated.
Show dataingredient-akebi-peel —is_documented_as_having→ "The author's summary that pretreatment by heating with added salt and water-soaking reduced the bitterness to some degree"
claim: clm-akebi-peel-preprocessing-bitter-reduction / type: processing / updated: 2026-09-16

The eating record still carries a range, though. A tasting record notes dishes running from ones where no bitterness was felt to ones faintly bitter and recognisably akebi.

akebi peel — sensory attribute: The author's tasting record that, depending on the dish, ranged from ones with no perceived bitterness to ones that were faintly bitter and tasted distinctly of akebiobservation

Scope: A single dining experience in Okura Village by the article's author

Note: Not a sensory test using a trained panel or a bitterness-intensity scale.

The author distinguishes the akebi dishes at dinner into 『苦味がないもの』 (in translation: "ones with no bitterness") and 『ほんのり苦味があってあけびらしいもの』 (in translation: "ones with a faint bitterness that tastes distinctly of akebi"). Bitterness is described not as a monolithic property fixed to the peel, but as something whose expression changes with the form of the dish.
Limitations: A personal, qualitative impression; ingredients, heating conditions, and bitterness intensity by dish were not measured.
Source: あけびの肉味噌のせ (林野庁, 2015) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-akebi-peel —has_sensory_attribute→ "The author's tasting record that, depending on the dish, ranged from ones with no perceived bitterness to ones that were faintly bitter and tasted distinctly of akebi"
claim: clm-akebi-dish-bitterness-range / type: sensory / updated: 2026-08-31

Edible chrysanthemum is described as having a crisp texture and a well-liked faint bitterness. That the bitterness sits on the liked side rather than the faulty one echoes the saying about the spring plate.

edible chrysanthemum — sensory attribute: a crisp, crunchy texture and a favored horonigai (gently bitter) flavorcontextual

Scope: a MAFF (Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries) resource introducing Yamagata Prefecture's edible-chrysanthemum culture

Note: Not a sensory panel test, but an official explanation of local cuisine.

States that many prefectural residents favor its distinctive crisp, crunchy texture and horonigai (gently bitter) flavor.
Limitations: Not a quantitative preference survey.
Source: 食用ぎくのおひたし 山形県 (農林水産省) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-edible-chrysanthemum —has_sensory_attribute→ "a crisp, crunchy texture and a favored horonigai (gently bitter) flavor"
claim: clm-japan-chrysanthemum-horonigai / type: sensory / updated: 2026-08-31

The season and the occasion are recorded too: the peak from autumn into early winter, and the food culture of the Chrysanthemum Festival.

edible chrysanthemum is consumed in The season from autumn to early winter and the food custom of Chōyō no Sekku.contextual

Scope: Yamagata Prefecture. 「もってのほか」 (in translation: "Mottenohoka") appears from late October to early November; yellow chrysanthemums are served on September 9.

Note: Breeding has broadened the period in which flowers can be harvested.

The source records the season, the harvest period of Mottenohoka, and the availability of yellow chrysanthemums on September 9 for Chōyō no Sekku.
Limitations: Harvest periods vary by cultivar.
Source: 食用ぎくのおひたし 山形県 (農林水産省) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-edible-chrysanthemum —is_consumed_in→ "The season from autumn to early winter and the food custom of Chōyō no Sekku."
claim: clm-japan-chrysanthemum-season / type: cultural / updated: 2026-08-31

Where the bitterness sits is given as a part: the centre of the flower, the tightly closed portion corresponding to the stamens and receptacle.

edible chrysanthemum — perceived bitterness is associated with: The flower center, the tightly closed part corresponding to the stamens and receptacle.contextual

Scope: An article on preparing edible chrysanthemums by porridge researcher 「鈴木かゆ」 (Suzuki Kayu) on note.com.

Note: An individual cooking researcher’s description, not a sensory-panel test. It cites bitterness as the reason for collecting only the petals and removing the flower center.

The article explains that only the petals are used because 「ぎゅっとすぼんだまんなかの部分は苦い」 (in translation: "the tightly closed middle part is bitter"). It also says 「しっかりと下ごしらえをした食用菊は、小さなお子様でも食べられるくらい苦味がありません」 (in translation: "edible chrysanthemums prepared thoroughly have so little bitterness that even small children can eat them").
Limitations: An individual cooking article without supporting sensory-panel or chemical analysis.
Source: 食用菊の基本の下ごしらえ いつもの食卓でたのしむ重陽の節句 (鈴木かゆ(お粥研究家)) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-edible-chrysanthemum —has_perceived_bitterness_associated_with→ "The flower center, the tightly closed part corresponding to the stamens and receptacle."
claim: clm-aprep-chrysanthemum-core-bitter / type: sensory / updated: 2026-09-13

Adding vinegar when boiling, on the other hand, is not for the bitterness. Its stated purpose is to bring out the colour and prevent discolouration — kept here as a case where a step is not necessarily there for the bitterness.

edible chrysanthemum is prepared by: Adding vinegar when boiling, a preparation step described as intended to preserve color and prevent discoloration.contextual

Scope: 2 independent sources on boiling edible chrysanthemums: FoodsLink’s 「旬の野菜百科」 (in translation: "Seasonal Vegetable Encyclopedia"; Shun no Yasai Hyakka) and note.com by Suzuki Kayu.

Note: The 2 sources describe the role of vinegar as 「発色」 (in translation: "color development"), preventing browning and preserving vivid color; neither describes a bitterness-reducing effect. An initial automatic web-search summary had incorrectly paraphrased the FoodsLink text as 「苦味を抑える」 (in translation: "suppressing bitterness"), so the original was checked directly and the account corrected.

The source says 「酢を加えることで綺麗な色に仕上がります。入れずにゆでると茶色くなってしまい、台無しになります」 (in translation: "Adding vinegar gives a beautiful color. Boiling without it turns the flowers brown and spoils them") and recommends about 30–50 cc vinegar per 1 liter water. It never uses the word bitterness in its text.
Limitations: A commercial food-encyclopedia website without peer review or sensory-panel support.
Source: 食用菊 もってのほか かきのもとのゆで方 (FoodsLink(フーズリンク)) · full text checked
The source says 「酢は色止めの役割。お酢を入れることで、鮮やかな菊の色を楽しむことができます」 (in translation: "Vinegar preserves the color. Adding it lets you enjoy the vivid color of the chrysanthemums").
Limitations: An individual cooking article without supporting sensory-panel or chemical analysis.
Source: 食用菊の基本の下ごしらえ いつもの食卓でたのしむ重陽の節句 (鈴木かゆ(お粥研究家)) · full text checked
Show dataingredient-edible-chrysanthemum —is_prepared_by→ "Adding vinegar when boiling, a preparation step described as intended to preserve color and prevent discoloration."
claim: clm-aprep-chrysanthemum-vinegar-color-not-bitterness / type: culinary / updated: 2026-09-13

Finally, one record of spring in another language. In Korea, spring greens are introduced as something whose faint bitterness is enjoyed together with their aroma and the sense of the season. The same shape of telling as the saying about the spring plate exists elsewhere.

Korea — cultural role: savoring the faint bitterness of spring greens together with their aroma and sense of seasoncontextual

Scope: a Korean government cultural magazine's introduction to spring namul

Note: Not a survey that measured nationwide preference frequency.

Introduces spring greens as a slightly bitter but delicious and fragrant seasonal ingredient, naming ssumbagwi as an example.
Limitations: Not a preference survey or a frequency survey.
Source: Spring Greens: A Healthy Taste Sprouts From the Earth (Yoon Se-eun; Kim Jin-hee; Kim Ga-young, 2015) · full text checked
Show dataregion-korea —has_cultural_role_of→ "savoring the faint bitterness of spring greens together with their aroma and sense of season"
claim: clm-korea-spring-greens-bitter-valued / type: cultural / updated: 2026-08-31

There is a record on the strongly bitter side as well. In the southern provinces of Korea, godulbaegi, a wild Asteraceae green, is known as a vegetable with a strong bitter taste and is used as a kimchi ingredient.

Korea — cultural role: In southern Korea, the daisy-family wild plant godulbaegi (Ixeris sonchifolia, also called Korean lettuce) is known as a vegetable with strong bitterness and is used for kimchi.supported

Scope: Layer: Literature (background account in a peer-reviewed journal).

"In the southern province of Korea, Ixeris sonchifolia Hance is a wild vegetable with a strong bitter taste, known as Godulbaegi (Korean lettuce) and belonging to the dandelion genus (Taraxacum) of the Asteraceae (also termed Compositae) family."
Limitations: The text calls the plant Ixeris but in the same sentence also says 『dandelion genus (Taraxacum)』; its genus designation is inconsistent.
Source: Effect of Fermentation Duration on the Quality Changes of Godulbaegi Kimchi (Park JM; Zhang BZ; Kim JM, 2022) · full text checked
Show dataregion-korea —has_cultural_role_of→ "In southern Korea, the daisy-family wild plant godulbaegi (Ixeris sonchifolia, also called Korean lettuce) is known as a vegetable with strong bitterness and is used for kimchi."
claim: clm-w72e1-korea-godulbaegi-species-bitter / type: cultural / updated: 2026-09-08

Its preparation, as a peer-reviewed paper records it, is to soak it in 5% brine for 48 hours and then wash it 3 times. The original wording is "to bring out the bitter taste," which can be read as drawing the bitterness out in the sense of heightening it. Against Japanese aku removal, which is spoken of as reducing bitterness, the direction here cannot be settled.

Korea — cultural role: The peer-reviewed journal states that godulbaegi, a strongly bitter wild plant harvested for kimchi, is soaked in 5% brine for 48 hours, washed with water 3 times, and then seasoned. The source calls this 『to bring out the bitter taste』.supported

Scope: Layer: food (description of the kimchi-preparation process).

Note: The original expression (to bring out) could suggest intensifying bitterness, but salting is also commonly used in traditional Korean preparation to lessen bitterness. The text alone cannot determine whether enhancement or reduction was intended, so the original wording is recorded without changing the direction by interpretation.

"Godulbaegi was soaked in 5% brine for 48 h to bring out the bitter taste, then washed 3 times under running water and drained for 30 min."
Limitations: The original expression (to bring out) could suggest intensifying bitterness, while salting wild plants in traditional Korean preparation can also lessen bitterness and acridity. The text alone does not establish whether the purpose was enhancement or reduction; the original wording is recorded without asserting a direction.
Source: Effect of Fermentation Duration on the Quality Changes of Godulbaegi Kimchi (Park JM; Zhang BZ; Kim JM, 2022) · full text checked
Show dataregion-korea —has_cultural_role_of→ "The peer-reviewed journal states that godulbaegi, a strongly bitter wild plant harvested for kimchi, is soaked in 5% brine for 48 hours, washed with water 3 times, and then seasoned. The source calls this 『to bring out the bitter taste』."
claim: clm-w72e1-korea-godulbaegi-brining-process / type: culinary / updated: 2026-09-08

The prep ledger and what to check in the kitchen

Whether specific pretreatment steps — salting, blanching, soaking in water — moved bitterness has not yet progressed to the point of covering sansai in any real number, but they are gathered, ingredient by ingredient, as rows in the prep ledger. Pretreatments whose names alone have been passed down without a connected source, and framings such as "sansai bitterness has a reason," are kept apart from fact and placed in the hypothesis box. What can be checked in the kitchen and what has been confirmed by sources are kept separate.

Frequently asked

Does aku removal actually remove fukinoto's bitterness?

The isolation study of fukinoto's bitter compounds reports that almost no bitterness transferred with hot water or dilute alcohol. However, this was an experimental procedure for extracting the bitter compounds, not an experiment measuring the effect of household blanching or soaking in water. So how much kitchen-level aku removal reduces bitterness cannot be confirmed from this source. For other sansai, a source dealing with the relationship between aku removal and bitterness itself has not yet been reached.

Are the bitter compounds of sansai known?

Within what has been confirmed, bitter compounds that have been isolated and named are limited to fukinoto and yomogi. In fukinoto, bakkenolide B, isopetasin, and fukinone; in yomogi, 2 sesquiterpene compounds isolated from the aerial parts have been reported to show a stronger bitterness than caffeine. The same yomogi's major flavonoids showed no confirmed bitterness. For other foods listed as sansai — warabi, zenmai, yamaudo, and others — a source at the compound level naming bitterness has not yet been connected.

Does "pile bitterness onto the spring plate" really come from Ishizuka Sagen?

Many food-culture media attribute it to a passage in a book by Ishizuka Sagen, a Meiji-era physician and pharmacist. However, the quoted wording differs between sources in its final word. A different poetry collection published in 1906 did contain the phrase "spring bitterness" together with a verse lining up the seasons, but a sentence containing the word assigned to winter could not be read through on the spot. Some media use the same saying as a headline without mentioning Ishizuka Sagen, explaining it only as referring mainly to spring vegetables. A source that can settle the origin to one has not been reached.

Are tara-no-me and shidoke also known as bitter sansai?

Tara-no-me is entered in the saijiki as a kigo for mid-spring, with bitterness mentioned in its commentary. For shidoke, a description naming a slight bitterness can be found in food-introduction text. Neither, however, is a source that measured the compounds — both remain word-level records, in a saijiki commentary or an introduction. The strength of the bitterness or the name of the compound cannot be determined from sources at this level.

What is not known

Read in the encyclopedia

The encyclopedia entries below are in Japanese.

All entries in this hub (37)

Every encyclopedia entry that belongs to this hub, grouped by category. Entries without an English version open in Japanese.

ingredientakebi peel · ashitaba · itadori (Japanese knotweed) · ginkgo nut · kogomi (ostrich fern) · Japonicalia delphiniifolia · edible chrysanthemum · ssumbagwi greens · tara-no-me (Aralia elata shoot) · nanohana (nabana) · nigana greens · Hassaku · fukinoto (butterbur flower bud) · yomogi greens · bamboo shoot · warabi (bracken) · ukogi (Eleutherococcus) · zenmai (Osmunda japonica) · Phyllostachys edulis · tsuwabuki · Mishima udo · yamaudo (Aralia cordata)

dishnamul · bakke miso · nigana shiraae · tsuwabuki oil stir-fry

organismIxeris dentata · Japanese butterbur (fuki) · Crepidiastrum lanceolatum · Eleutherococcus trifoliatus

compoundbakkenolide B

compound classpyrrolizidine alkaloids

processaku-nuki (blanch-and-soak treatment) · boiling of vegetables

concept"Fill the spring plate with bitterness" (Japanese saying) · "Good medicine is bitter in the mouth" (Japanese proverb)

regionKorea

Go deeper in the research notes

Source ledger

The primary sources and limitations behind the claims listed here can each be checked from the source links inside their cards. The full list is gathered in the Source ledger.

How to cite this page

Aoki, M. (NIGAMI LAB) (2026). Sansai and seasonal bitterness. https://nigamilab.com/en/topics/sansai/

Each claim card has a stable anchor (#clm-…). The dataset is CC BY 4.0; see the data page. Dataset DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22739101